Electric wheelchairs have become a huge convenience for people who, due to motor problems or the inability to work with their hands, have to rely largely on the help of a wheeling chair. An electric wheelchair controlled with a joystick allows easy movement both at home and outside without the need to manually set the wheelchair in motion. In recent years, mobility scooters have become an alternative mobility device to electric wheelchairs, which are mainly used on a daily basis by seniors and people with slightly greater motor skills. So, which type of vehicle is worth considering, and in what situations will they work best?
Advantages and Disadvantages of Mobility Aids
If you’re new to mobility aids, you may wonder whether an electric Power Wheelchair vs Mobility Scooter is a better choice. This decision depends on your individual needs, such as the level of your disability and the conditions in which you plan to use the device. There are advantages and disadvantages to both. But first, you should consult your doctor, who will tell you if you need medical aid.
Electric Wheelchair Overview
An electric wheelchair is a motorized medical device. It’s a great option for people with disabilities that allows them to move without having to use muscle power. A motorized chair is powered by an electric motor. You move in different directions and overcome various obstacles or uneven terrain. An electric wheelchair for adults is equipped with motion controllers, a seat, armrests, a backrest, safety belts, and a battery that powers the electric motor. Electric wheelchairs are engineered to allow the user the greatest possible independence and freedom in everyday life.
If you rarely walk or never walk at all, this Power Wheelchair vs Mobility Scooter can make your daily life much easier.
Pros
- A foldable wheelchair fits easily into the car
- Designed for both indoor and outdoor use
- Adjustable parts (backrest, armrests, footrest)
Cons
- Most models perform better on flat terrain and worse on gravel or grass
- No space to carry groceries
- Less speed and range than scooters
Who Are Electric Wheelchairs Recommended for?
From the perspective of physiotherapists, if a disabled person has the ability to move independently in a manual wheelchair, this option will be the best for them and will provide the necessary amount of movement to strengthen the upper body. An Power Wheelchair vs Mobility Scooter can be a supplement to a manual wheelchair for such people, but it should not be its complete substitute. The greater profitability of investing in an electric wheelchair appears among people who do not have the strength to move independently in a manual wheelchair but who want to maintain a certain level of independence.
Mobility Scooter Overview
Electric mobility scooters usually come in available in three-wheeled and four-wheeled models. Four-wheeled models are more stable and perform better on uneven surfaces. They can be used on dirt paths or other difficult terrain without any problems. While an electric wheelchair is suitable for people with severe mobility limitations, a scooter supports people who can still move short distances. This is very important for people who plan to use an Power Wheelchair vs Mobility Scooter in small, tight spaces, often drive into shops, do some gardening, or even maneuver a lot when entering or leaving a lift.
Pros
- Can reach max speeds of up to 15 mph
- Adapted to difficult terrain conditions
- Space for transporting purchases
- Suitable for longer distances
- Comfortable seat
Cons
- Not all models are easy to transport
- Limited indoor use
- Higher purchase costs
- Requires minimal mobility and driving skills
Who Can Benefit From a Mobility Scooter?
A mobility scooter is not a good choice for everyone. It is recommended for seniors who have difficulty moving and people with disabilities, but it will not work for those who need additional stability to maintain a proper sitting position. An electric wheelchair will be a much better option for them, especially when it comes to ease of control and a smaller range of necessary movements – electric wheelchairs are simply safer and more stable in such situations. Charging the batteries is also less of a problem – the ones in used mobility scooters are larger and require a longer charging time, and due to the higher driving speed, they do not always guarantee a longer distance to cover with a full battery.
Good advice: make sure your wheelchair has lights and reflectors. This will make you visible on the roads and sidewalks. Remember not to exceed walking speed on sidewalks.
Comparison: Electric Wheelchair vs Electric Mobility Scooter?
As you can see, both mobility devices pose their advantages and disadvantages. So, here are some extra tips will help you decide between these two mobility devices.
Choose an electric wheelchair if:
- Your mobility is very limited.
- You need the device mainly for indoor mobility.
- Outdoors, short distances are enough for you.
- You care about the possibility of transporting the stroller by car.
Choose an electric mobility scooter if:
- You are able to walk short distances independently.
- You’re doing fine at home, but outside you need support.
- You can navigate safely in road traffic.
- You want to use the scooter for shopping, walking, or meeting friends.
- The ability to transport your vehicle by car is not a necessity for you.
Good advice: Don’t be afraid of the purchase costs. In many cases, it is possible to obtain financial support for the purchase of the device. Some programs like Medicare can cover the costs of mobility aids. Contact your doctor to get more info on this.
Summary
Disability is a condition that can be dealt with well in the twenty-first century. Thanks to many specially designed technical solutions and innovative projects, people affected by various types of mobility and health diseases can enjoy, to a large extent, the same life as those who are completely healthy. One of the main things that influence this condition is, of course, various types of communication and infrastructure facilities, such as platforms, elevators, tilting handles, but above all, mobility scooters and various types of wheelchairs designed for these people.
